Skip to main content

Peirson’s Milk-vetch: BLM Monitoring Reports & OHV Impacts

Thousands of Plants Counted. Very Little Documented OHV Damage.

For years, Peirson’s milk-vetch (PMV), a federally protected plant found in the Imperial Sand Dunes, has been at the center of debates over recreation access, environmental protection, and the management of our public lands.

But what does the actual monitoring data tell us? According to the Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) Peirson’s milk-vetch monitoring reports from 2014 through 2026, 78,625 plants were counted, with just 48 recorded as damaged by off-highway vehicles (OHVs). That’s approximately 0.061% of the total plants counted.

In other words, roughly six plants per 10,000 counted were documented as damaged by OHVs. In addition, Rainfall appears to play the largest role in PMV populations – see graphs below.

During the same reporting periods, the BLM recorded 1,728 instances of plant damage attributed to non-OHV causes.

These numbers raise an important question: Are current (or past) restrictions on motorized recreation supported by the most recent scientific evidence?

The American Sand Association believes public-land management decisions should be based on sound science, current information, and documented impacts—not assumptions about recreational activity. The table below summarizes the BLM’s annual monitoring results, with links to the original reports so duners, land managers, and the public can examine the evidence for themselves.

The numbers deserve a closer look. So do the decisions they inform.

The following Peirson’s milk-vetch (PMV) monitoring reports were prepared by the Bureau of Land Management’s El Centro Field Office (BLM ECFO).

THE NUMBERS BEHIND THE PEIRSON’S MILK-VETCH DEBATE

Report YearTotal plants CountedPlants Damaged by OHVsPlants Non-OHV DamageDownload
2014–20155,03810Download 2014–2015 Report (PDF)
20166,04720Download 2016 Report (PDF)
201718,8263194Download 2017 Report (PDF)
2018523290Download 2018 Report (PDF)
201913,4631126Download 2019 Report (PDF)
202018,00419Download 2020 Report (PDF)
20211,26100Download 2021 Report (PDF)
202226410Download 2022 Report (PDF)
202357015Download 2023 Report (PDF)
20242,775090Download 2024 Report (PDF)
20257409Download 2025 Report (PDF)
202612,29301385Download 2026 Report (PDF)
Totals78,62548 – 0.061%1728 – 2.19%1776 – 2.25%

*2018 Data Categorization: In the 2018 report, surveyors recorded 8,314 standing dead plants (from the massive 2017 germination cohort) under the “Non-OHV Damage” category and in total plants counted. In subsequent reports, USFWS and BLM botanists noted this reporting issue and updated data collection protocols to separate standing dead plants from live plants experiencing non-OHV damage. 523 was the actual number of active live plants in 2018. No non-OHV damaged plants were noted.

RAINFALL TIMING IS a CRUCIAL COMPONENT of PMV GERMINATION

  • Impact of Missing October–December Rain
    • Germination Failure: When rainfall during October–December is absent or well below average (such as 0.00 inches in Oct–Dec 2020 and Oct–Dec 2024), seed germination drops dramatically or fails entirely for that cycle.
    • In years with zero early winter rain (e.g., 2005–2006 and 2024–2025), virtually no new PMV seedlings germinated out of the seed bank
  • Atypical Off-Season Rain Events
    • Heavy late-summer or early-fall storms (such as August or September rains) occasionally wet the sand dunes prior to the official October growing season start. These atypical rain events can trigger unseasonal early germination or provide baseline moisture that enhances subsequent winter seedling survival.

Reported tracks by access status and PMV vehicle damage

Survey yearOpenClosedTotalAnnual PMV damage countReport context
2014128141420
2015434285142 tracks were in closed critical-habitat plots.
20163414      345*2Later table splits 341 open and 4 closed; see note.
2017245175351 closed-area tracks, including 48 in Macroplot 19.
201858861442986 closed-area tracks in Macroplot 19, attributed to Border Patrol; dead-plant issue was in a separate category.
2019875831175 tracks in closure areas (90%); Macroplot 19 had 45 truck-type tracks.
20204371114171 closed-area tracks (62.3%); 43 in open plots.
2021740740All 74 recorded tracks were in open plots; none recorded in closed plots.
2022275132881275 open-area tracks; 13 in closed Macroplot 19.
20232691273960269 open-area tracks; 127 closed, including 101 in Macroplot 19.
20243828503 open-area tracks; 82 closed, including 81 in Macroplot 19.
2025154863015 open-area tracks; 48 closed, including 42 in Macroplot 19 and 6 in Macroplot 16.
2026936105   1,039**0Macroplot chart: 936 open + 105 closed; report narrative total differs by 2.
Total2217718293348

Annual trend counts sum to 48 observations, not 48 unique plants; the reports provide no cross-year identifiers. The original 2018 report listed 50 OHV-damaged plants, while later summaries use 29. Later reports say the 2018 and 2019 reports were revised after erroneous non-OHV classifications. In 2018, 8,314 plants were listed under non-OHV damage, mostly standing dead, and could not be reliably separated from live plants with non-OHV damage. The report also notes that not all OHV-damage observations mapped to tracks. 

* The 2016 report narrative gives 325 total tracks, with 321 open-area and 4 closed-area tracks. The 2017 cumulative table instead records 341 open and 4 closed, for a total of 345; the table and chart use that later plot-level breakdown.

** The 2026 macroplot chart sums to 1,041 tracks (936 open and 105 closed), while the report narrative gives 1,039 total. The table retains the narrative total and reports the area split from the macroplot chart.

Open/closed status follows the report’s classification of the monitored macroplots for that year. Closed-area tracks are tracks observed within closed macroplots, not an estimate of all OHV use inside closures. The distribution varied: for example, all 74 tracks recorded in 2021 were in open plots, while 82 of 85 tracks in 2024 were in closed plots. These counts do not establish whether any given track was recreational, nor do they measure indirect effects such as erosion.

OHV Damage Counts by Open and Closed Plots

Survey yearOpen plots
OHV-damaged plants
Closed plots
OHV-damaged plants
Annual totalReport basis / qualification
20140002014–2015 report
20151012014–2015 report; damage recorded in open Macroplot 8
20162022016 report; damage recorded in open Macroplot 8
20170332017 report; damage recorded in closed Macroplot 19
2018 revised trendNot reportedNot reported29Later trend summaries use 29; revised plot split unavailable. Original 2018 report: 1 open, 49 closed (50 total).
2019011112019 report; all 11 in closed plots
20200112020 report; damage recorded in closed Macroplot 15
20210002021 report
20221012022 report; damage recorded in open Macroplot 6
20230002023 report
20240002024 report
20250002025 report
20260002026 report
Sum of annual totals——48Uses the revised 2018 trend total; annual observations are not unique-plant counts.

If you have questions on the reports you can refer them to the BLM El Centro Field Office:
Bureau of Land Management
1661 S. 4th St
El Centro, CA 92243
Office: (760) 337-4425

Of course, your comments are welcomed below.

FAQs about PMV Critical Habitat from 2004 studies/reports

BLM El Centro Office Home Page

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Accessibility Toolbar