Comments on the Johnson Valley DEIS Deadline May 26, 2011

No fences. Non area specific. General discussion forum.

Moderator: Sitewide Forum Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
Vincent J Brunasso
ASA Co-Founder • Past President
ASA Co-Founder • Past President
Posts: 2723
Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2000 8:05 pm
antispam: NO
Please enter the middle number: 7

Comments on the Johnson Valley DEIS Deadline May 26, 2011

Post by Vincent J Brunasso »


Submit Comments on the Johnson Valley Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) Deadline for submission is May 26, 2011!

The American Motorcyclist Association (AMA) is encouraging riders to submit their comments regarding the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center proposed base expansion. This proposed enlargement of the facility could restrict your ability to access the Johnson Valley Off-Highway Vehicle Recreation Area. Comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) are due by May 26, 2011 in order to be considered in the final EIS.

They can either be submitted using the official comments website

or the following mailing address:
Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Southwest
ATTN: 29Palms EIS Project Manager
1220 Pacific Highway
San Diego, CA 92132-5190

The DEIS analyzes potential environmental impacts associated with the proposed base expansion. To download a copy of the DEIS (941 pages), or to find where hard copies are available for review, click here.

The AMA has been working with a number of concerned groups on this issue and had previously submitted comments during the scoping phase of the DEIS.

Based on our review, the "no action" alternative is simply the only acceptable option.

Johnson Valley History: The recreating public has enjoyed the open expanses of the Johnson Valley for at least the past 50 years. Located in San Bernardino County, California, this 189,000 acre open area is the largest remaining area of public land in the Western United States, and current estimates are that 800,000 - 1,000,000 visitors recreate throughout the area annually.

Activities currently enjoyed include traditional family camping and Off-Highway Vehicle (OHV) recreating, motorcycle and 4x4 competitions, rock hounding, hiking and wildlife viewing. In addition, the open landscape has made the area popular with the film industry. Johnson Valley presents an unparalleled landscape for the OHV enthusiast. It is punctuated by steep red mountains, rolling hills, open valleys, dry lakebeds and sandy washes. Elevations range from 2,300 feet at Melville Dry Lake to 4,600 feet at Hartwell Hills.

The eastern boundary is shared with the Twenty-nine Palms Marine Air-Ground Combat Center. It is used for everything from competitive racing events to casual family OHV recreation, gem and mineral collecting, rocketry, land sailing and disbursed camping. No other designated "open" area in the California desert, or indeed the entire United States, provides such a variety of recreational opportunities to the general public.

According to the California State Off- Highway Motor Vehicle Recreation Division (OHMVR), between 1980 and 2007 the number of registered OHVs statewide has increased by 370%. However, since 1980, the amount of dessert lands available for this type of recreation has fallen dramatically. In fact, recent Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management (BLM) user surveys show an ever-increasing demand for these types of motorized recreational activities and areas. Johnson Valley is one of the most important areas left for serving this growing demand for both in state and out of state visitors.

Specific Comments When commenting on the DEIS it is important to include your personal experiences and stories. Many issues that were raised during the scoping phase of the process have been responded to by the Marines in the DEIS. These replies are summarized in Chapter 6, Summary of Project Impacts, Mitigation Measures and Cumulative Impacts, of the DEIS. The economic impacts of this project are potentially substantial to the surrounding communities and the nation's economy.

Riders are asked to share their specific experience and personal stories in their comment letter. The most effective comment is an original one that tells your story. Examples of substantive comments would include specific statements about the frequency of your visits to the area; the amount of money spent per visit and other economic-related information. Another important point would be a statement about how this loss of opportunity would force you and your family to frequent other recreation areas. The impact of displaced recreationists on other recreation areas is significant and will result in increased pressure on other area BLM and state lands throughout southern California and the surrounding states.

The following is a suggested format for your letter, but is only meant to be a guide. Personal experiences and stories will be more persuasive than simple blanket statement indicating support for a specific alternative or opposition to the expansion plan in general.

To date, the Marine Corp. has not provided an email address for submission of official comments. Therefore your comments must either be printed out and mailed by the official deadline (May 26) or submitted via the official comments website.

Sample text
I am writing for two purposes: (1) to register my objection to the Twenty-nine Palms Training Land Acquisition Project, and (2) to notify you that the DEIS for the project is defective with respect to its analysis of project-related impacts on the local economy, impacts for which no meaningful mitigation has been offered.

From my perspective, the only alternative I can support is the "No Action" alternative. Only the "No Action" alternative would allow continued public recreation in Johnson Valley at its current levels and also avoid economic impacts and disruptions to the surrounding communities.

My family recreates in the Johnson Valley OHV area (enter #) times a year. Our favorite places to visit in Johnson Valley are (name of specific location) , where we engage in such activities as (___) and (____).

When preparing for a trip, we spend $ (enter amount) on fuel, groceries, and other supplies in our local area. Then, we spend an additional $ (enter amount) in the Johnson Valley/Lucerne Valley/Victorville area while we are recreating. Over the years, we have patronized the following businesses (names of business), among others, in the Johnson Valley/Lucerne Valley/Victorville Area: If Johnson Valley, or any part of it, were to be closed due to the expansion of the Twenty-nine Palms Marine Corps Air-Ground Combat Center, there would be no reason for my family to travel to this part of the desert. Therefore, we would no longer spend money in Johnson Valley, Lucerne Valley, Victorville, or the other small communities that currently serve the recreating public near the proposed project site.

As written, the DEIS provides an inadequate and incomplete analysis of the project's potential impacts on the local economy. The analysis is based on unproven assumptions that contradict both common sense and my own experiences as a frequent and long-standing visitor to Johnson Valley. To suggest that the proposed Project, including the "Preferred Alternative," would result in anything other than the significant disruptions of the local economy is misleading and speculative in nature. This part of the DEIS, among others, must be completely revised and until such action is taken I can only support the "No Action" alternative.

Thank you for taking the time to consider my comments on this important matter.

Again, the official website for submitting your comments is or via the U.S. Postal Service at:
Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Southwest
ATTN: 29Palms EIS Project Manager
1220 Pacific Highway
San Diego, CA 92132-5190
Vincent J. Brunasso
ASA Co-Founder and past president

“My reading of history convinces me that most bad government results from too much government.”
--Thomas Jefferson

5th Gear "Pinned" Member
5th Gear "Pinned" Member
Posts: 453
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 9:31 pm
Please enter the middle number: 5
Location: pauma valley

Re: Comments on the Johnson Valley DEIS Deadline May 26, 201

Post by alyshka »

Somewhat good news
From the AMA

Dec. 19, 2012   

Media contact: James Holter
Phone: (614) 856-1900, ext. 1280
California's popular Johnson Valley riding area may get reprieve from military base expansion
PICKERINGTON, Ohio -- Riders who use the popular Johnson Valley Off-Highway Vehicle Riding Area in California may not lose most of the area to a Marine base expansion after all, the American Motorcyclist Association reports.

The military is barred from spending money on expanding the Twentynine Palms military base into Johnson Valley until it completes a report on how the expansion would affect off-highway riding, under a military spending authorization bill approved by U.S. House and Senate conferees on Dec. 18.

"The report to Congress would cover the impact on off-highway vehicle recreation in the Johnson Valley region, along with alternatives for achieving the goals of the military and the OHV recreation communities," said Wayne Allard, AMA vice president for government relations. "This report would allow for more time to, hopefully, come to a solution that meets the training needs of the military while maintaining access for motorized recreation."

The language, included in the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2013 (H.R. 4310), was offered by Rep. Roscoe Bartlett (R-Md.) with support from Sens. Diane Feinstein (D-Calif.) and Mark Udall (D-Colo.). House and Senate negotiators worked out their differences over the bill in a conference committee and then sent it to their respective chambers for final approval. Once approved by both chambers, it goes to the president to be signed into law.

"The AMA, in partnership with the California Motorized Recreation Council and The Livingston Group in Washington, D.C., that was hired by the CMRC to move the legislation, worked long and hard to get this important report required before the base expansion can proceed," Allard said.

The California Motorized Recreation Council is a non-profit association comprised of the leadership of the largest off-highway vehicle recreation organizations in California. CMRC membership includes, the Off-Road Business Association, California Association of 4-Wheel Drive Clubs, California Off-Road Vehicle Association, AMA national, American Sand Association, California-Nevada Snowmobile Association, AMA District 36 (Northern California, Northwestern Nevada) and AMA District 37 (Southern California) Off-Road.

"I particularly want to thank Rep. Bartlett and Sens. Feinstein and Udall for their efforts," Allard said.

"This was truly a team effort involving many southern California motorized groups and their elected representatives in Washington, D.C., as well as other representatives in Congress," Allard said.

In July, the Department of the Navy released a final environmental impact statement for the expansion of the Marine base. The preferred alternative would allow public use of only 40,000 acres of the 190,000-acre Johnson Valley OHV area, and for only 10 months a year.

It's all part of an effort by the Marine Corps Air Ground Combat Center at Twentynine Palms to expand its land holdings to allow for more live-fire training. The Marine Corps is part of the Navy.

The proposed expansion needs congressional approval. The military had hoped to begin training on the land in 2014.

Several years ago, the Navy began the formal process to take over some 365,906 acres of public land near San Bernardino to use for live-fire training for the Marines.

At that time, the Navy filed an application with the U.S. Interior Department seeking control of the public land, which is under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Bureau of Land Management. The Navy also wants priority for some 72,186 acres of non-federal land in case the federal government acquires it.
About the American Motorcyclist Association
Since 1924, the AMA has protected the future of motorcycling and promoted the motorcycle lifestyle. AMA members come from all walks of life, and they navigate many different routes on their journey to the same destination: freedom on two wheels. As the world's largest motorcycling rights organization, the AMA advocates for motorcyclists' interests in the halls of local, state and federal government, the committees of international governing organizations, and the court of public opinion. Through member clubs, promoters and partners, the AMA sanctions more motorsports competition and motorcycle recreational events than any other organization in the world. AMA members receive money-saving discounts from dozens of well-known suppliers of motorcycle services, gear and apparel, bike rental, transport, hotel stays and more. Through the AMA Motorcycle Hall of Fame, the AMA honors the heroes and the heritage of motorcycling for future generations. For more information,
Robert Hancock
"The task that has fallen to us as Americans is to keep alive the hope and dream of freedom"
Ronald Reagan
alyshka r.i.p. 1987-2004
Alyshka's Photos

User avatar
7th Gear "No Brakes" Member
7th Gear "No Brakes" Member
Posts: 2089
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 8:09 am
Please enter the middle number: 5
Location: Avacado Capital of the World

Re: Comments on the Johnson Valley DEIS Deadline May 26, 201

Post by Sandcock »

Thanks for the update Bro.
The real egalitarians are not the people who want to redistribute wealth to the poor, but those who want to extend to the poor the ability to create their own wealth, to lift themselves up, instead of trying to tear others down. Earning respect, including self-respect, is better than being a parasite. Thomas Sowell

Post Reply

Return to “Wide Open Sand”